Cost & Insurance

Employer Fertility Benefits: Carrot, Progyny and Treatment Abroad

Carrot and Progyny are built differently, and that difference decides whether your benefit can follow you to a clinic in another country.

October 30, 2026 · 8 min read · Last checked: October 30, 2026

Carrot and Progyny both run fertility benefits on behalf of employers, but they work in different ways. Carrot pays through a funded card or reimbursement against an employer-set limit, and says it offers navigation for care outside your home country where that is legal. Progyny uses in-network clinics, and the plan documents we reviewed exclude out-of-network care. Neither publicly promises that a US-based employee can use the benefit at any clinic abroad.

General information, not medical, legal or insurance advice.

Your employer designs your plan. What is covered, where, and for how much is set in your plan documents. Confirm with your benefits administrator, and make treatment decisions with a reproductive endocrinologist.

Key takeaways

  • Carrot says that, where legal, it offers care navigation for members seeking care outside their home country.
  • The Carrot Card is described as usable with eligible providers worldwide and supports 50 currencies, but eligibility is still plan-specific.
  • Progyny bundles treatment into "Smart Cycles" and, in a 2026 employer member guide, requires covered care at a Progyny in-network clinic.
  • Progyny's Global Support serves employers' international workforces in 175+ countries; it does not publicly address US members traveling abroad.
  • Get any approval for care abroad in writing before you book flights or pay a deposit.

Two models: funds vs. bundled cycles

Most employer fertility benefits fall into one of two designs. The difference matters more for treatment abroad than any other feature.

A fund-based benefit gives you a dollar amount to spend on eligible care. You pay with a benefit card or submit receipts for reimbursement. The money follows you, within the plan's rules.

A managed network benefit covers specific treatments at contracted clinics. Your clinic bills the administrator, and you pay cost-sharing through your medical plan. Coverage depends on where you go.

Carrot leans toward the first model. Progyny is built on the second. Both companies let employers customize plans heavily, so your own plan can differ from anything described here.

How Carrot works

Carrot describes itself as a fertility and family-forming benefit covering egg, sperm and embryo freezing, IVF and IUI, gestational surrogacy, adoption, pregnancy, menopause and men's health. Its home page says it serves members in 195+ countries with 17,000+ eligible providers.

The Carrot Card and reimbursement

According to Carrot's Carrot Card page, eligible members get the card through their benefit. It can sit in a phone wallet for payment at the point of care. Carrot says the card is designed for eligible providers worldwide, supports 50 currencies, and includes built-in currency conversion.

Carrot also handles reimbursement. One employer's Carrot FAQ, updated October 2025, says members need Carrot's approval and must use a Carrot-approved provider before they are eligible for reimbursement. That FAQ says reimbursements arrive within three weeks of submitting an expense.

Limits and tax treatment

Employers set the dollar cap. The University of Pennsylvania, for example, publishes a flat $30,000 lifetime maximum for its Carrot benefit, and routes fertility prescriptions through its separate pharmacy benefit.

Penn's page also splits expenses into two groups. Care that is medical for the employee, spouse or dependent is treated as a qualified medical expense. Donor, surrogacy and gestational carrier costs are treated as non-qualified and become taxable income on the employee's W-2. The Fisher FAQ describes the same split: diagnosis-related treatment isn't taxed, while adoption and surrogacy benefits are.

Why the tax split matters

If part of your benefit is taxable, set aside cash for the withholding. The Fisher FAQ says the full tax is withheld from the paycheck after you submit and can't be spread across several paychecks.

How Progyny works

Progyny describes its offering as fertility, pregnancy, menopause and family health benefits, delivered through employers. Every member is assigned a Progyny Care Advocate (PCA) who helps find a provider, schedule a first consultation and activate the benefit.

Smart Cycles

Progyny's coverage unit is the Smart Cycle. Each treatment uses a fraction of one. On Progyny's Smart Cycle page, a fresh IVF cycle uses 3/4, IUI uses 1/4, and egg freezing uses 1/2. Diagnostics, lab work, treatment and medication for that treatment are bundled inside the value.

Employers decide how many Smart Cycles you get. Bowdoin College's 2026 Progyny member guide lists three per family per lifetime, plus two initial consultations a year that don't draw down the balance.

Network and authorization

The Bowdoin guide is direct: covered treatment must be performed at a Progyny in-network clinic. Services from out-of-network providers are a standard exclusion, though the guide says exceptions may exist.

Authorization is required before your first appointment and before each treatment cycle. The guide adds that authorization is not a guarantee of payment. You still owe the deductible, coinsurance or copay set by your medical plan.

Medications

Progyny Rx covers specialty fertility drugs on its formulary. Its FAQ says prescriptions go to fertility specialty pharmacies in the US that ship by mail, in stages, often overnight. The FAQ does not address shipping abroad. Dispensed medication can't be returned or refunded.

What each says about care abroad

This is where most people's plans get stuck. Here is what each company says in its own published materials, and what it does not say.

Carrot

In an August 2024 article, Carrot says that where it is legal, it offers care navigation for members seeking care outside their home country. The same article says each country gets a specific level of support, reviewed annually, and that some services carry age, gender or marital status rules in certain countries.

Carrot also says it does not provide legal advice, but gives members access to a network of local attorneys. An earlier Carrot post gives examples of country limits, such as donor egg treatment not being allowed in Germany.

What Carrot does not publish: a blanket rule that any foreign clinic is eligible, or how travel and lodging are treated. Those are plan-level questions.

Progyny

Progyny's Global Support page says employers can extend benefits to their international workforce, delivered locally in 175+ countries with thousands of vetted clinics. It mentions a Progyny Card and reimbursement, with funding rules set by employers per country.

That product is aimed at employees who work abroad. Progyny's public pages do not say whether a US-based member on a standard plan can use the benefit at a clinic in Colombia, Mexico or Spain. Given the in-network requirement in the member guide we reviewed, assume no unless your PCA confirms otherwise in writing.

Don't assume coverage abroad

A foreign clinic accepting card payments is not the same as your benefit covering that clinic. If a charge is later found ineligible, you may owe it back or lose that part of your lifetime maximum.

Side-by-side comparison

Carrot vs. Progyny, from each company's public pages and published employer guides, checked Oct 30, 2026
FeatureCarrotProgyny
Core modelFunded benefit paid by card or reimbursementBundled "Smart Cycles" at contracted clinics
Who sets the limitEmployer (Penn example: $30,000 lifetime)Employer (Bowdoin example: 3 Smart Cycles per lifetime)
Provider rulesCarrot-approved provider (Fisher FAQ)In-network clinic required; exceptions possible (Bowdoin guide)
MedicationsCarrot Rx offered; some employers route drugs through their pharmacy planProgyny Rx formulary via US specialty pharmacies
SupportExperts and translated platform in 25+ languagesDedicated Patient Care Advocate
Stated global reach195+ countries175+ countries (Global Support)
Care outside home countryNavigation offered "where it is legal"Not addressed for US members
Currency handlingCard supports 50 currenciesNot stated

Your plan may differ. Employer examples are named only to show how limits are set, not as typical amounts.

Questions to ask before you travel

Call or message your benefit's care team before you choose a clinic. Ask for the answers in writing, and save them with your treatment records.

  1. Is care outside the US covered under my plan? Ask whether the answer depends on the country, the clinic, or the treatment.
  2. Does this specific clinic qualify? Give the clinic's legal name, address and medical director. Ask if it needs to be pre-approved.
  3. How will I pay? Card at the clinic, reimbursement after, or direct billing. Ask which currency and exchange rate apply.
  4. What documents do you need? Itemized invoices, translations, proof of payment, and medical records. Ask about format and deadlines.
  5. Are medications covered if bought abroad? Or only from a US pharmacy? Ask how controlled shipping works if you travel mid-cycle.
  6. Are travel and lodging covered? Ask whether any part is eligible and whether it would be taxable.
  7. How does this affect my lifetime maximum? Ask how partial or cancelled cycles are counted.

Before you commit to a foreign clinic, vet it on its own merits. Our guide to red flags when vetting a clinic abroad covers licensing, contracts and lab questions.

If your employer offers no fertility benefit, check whether your state requires coverage. Our overview of IVF insurance mandates by state explains which plans those laws reach. If you end up self-paying, read how to finance IVF abroad and pay safely.

Care team questions vs. clinic questions

The ASRM Ethics Committee's 2022 opinion on cross-border care flags a practical risk: patients often return home with little documentation of treatment abroad. Ask the foreign clinic up front for complete records in a format your home doctor can use.

Get a free consultation

Trying to line up your employer benefit with a clinic abroad? Request a free consultation to talk through options.

Get a free consultation

FAQ

Can I use Carrot for IVF in another country?

Possibly. Carrot says that where it is legal, it offers care navigation for members seeking care outside their home country, and its card is designed for eligible providers worldwide. Eligibility still depends on your employer's plan, so confirm the specific clinic with Carrot before you pay.

Does Progyny cover clinics outside the US?

Progyny's public pages don't say so for US-based members. A 2026 employer member guide requires covered treatment at a Progyny in-network clinic and excludes out-of-network care, with possible exceptions. Progyny's Global Support product is for employers' international workforces.

What is a Progyny Smart Cycle?

It is Progyny's unit of coverage. Each treatment uses a fraction: Progyny lists a fresh IVF cycle at 3/4, IUI at 1/4, and egg freezing at 1/2. Testing, lab work and medications for that treatment are bundled in. Your employer decides how many you get.

Is my fertility benefit taxable?

Medical care for you, your spouse or a dependent generally isn't, according to employer guides from Penn and Fisher. Surrogacy, donor and adoption benefits are treated as taxable and reported as income. Check your own plan's guide and a tax professional.

Can I deduct costs my benefit didn't cover?

Possibly, as an itemized medical deduction above 7.5% of AGI. You can't deduct anything the benefit reimbursed or paid. Keep receipts showing what you paid yourself.

This is general information, not medical, legal, insurance or tax advice.

Benefit terms change and differ by employer. Rely on your own plan documents and written answers from your administrator. For treatment decisions, consult a reproductive endocrinologist; for tax questions, a tax professional.

Sources

  1. Carrot home page — Carrot Fertility
  2. Carrot Card — Carrot Fertility
  3. Global reach, so we can grow together — Carrot Fertility
  4. How Carrot partners with customers to support global teams — Carrot Fertility
  5. How to find fertility benefits for your global workforce — Carrot Fertility
  6. Carrot Frequently Asked Questions (updated Oct 2025) — Fisher Investments
  7. Carrot Fertility — University of Pennsylvania Human Resources
  8. Progyny home page — Progyny
  9. What is a Smart Cycle? — Progyny
  10. Global Support — Progyny
  11. Support for individuals — Progyny
  12. Progyny Rx (Medication) Frequently Asked Questions — Progyny
  13. 2026 Progyny Member Guide — Bowdoin College Human Resources
  14. Publication 502, Medical and Dental Expenses — Internal Revenue Service
  15. Cross-border reproductive care: an Ethics Committee opinion (2022) — American Society for Reproductive Medicine